Phospholipases PLBD1 and PLBD2

Introduction

(to be continued shortly)

Conservation at critical sites

The six residues of PLBD2 associated with the active site are completely conserved within vertebrates to within genomic sequencing error. These same six residues are also completely conserved within PLBD1. Indeed 3 of the residues are conserved in the broader class of NTN hydrolases.

This is perhaps unsurprising since the active site was established a billion years earlier in the bacterial ancestor. However if PLBD2 and PLBD1 have different substrates, this establishes that these six residues are insufficient to distinguish the two active sites. Note H266 and T330 do not contribute their side chain, leaving them and W269 to separate phospholipases from the other NTN hydrolases.

The glycosylation sites are surprisingly conserved both within and between PLBD2 and PLBD1. Some of the motifs may be either recently acquired within later vertebrates or spurious glycosylation motifs with N and D both acceptable (or similar small amino acids). Glycosylation is important in targeting of lysosomal proteins, more so than in generic endoplasmic reticulum proteins where motifs are often poorly conserved (as in sulfatases).

PLBD2 has two established disulfides. Strict sequence conservation of these throughout vertebrates (indeed, throughout metazoa) suggests both play an important role in protein structure and stability.

In PLBD1 however, the first disulfide is not a possibility and while an opportunity exists for a disulfide homologous to the the second disulfide of PLBD2, indels cloud the alignment and spacing would have to be different. There is additionally ambiguity given C...CC as to the cysteines involved. Indeed a second distal disulfide may occur utilizing C...CC.............C which has no counterpart in PLBD2. While cysteines can be conserved for many reasons other than disulfide (as in the nucleophile cysteine here), suitably proximity and side chain orientation in the SwissModel of PLBD1 would argue for disulfide. Comparative genomics suggests that C2 and C4 may form an ancient disulfide whereas C1 and C3 might represent a deuterostome innovation.

homSap CNTICCREDLNSPNPSPGGC human PLBD1
braFlo CSAICCRKDLAKVGAKPDGC Branchiostoma floridae
strPur SKSICMRGDLM-TSPMPNGC Strongylocentrotus purpuratus XM_001192029 
nemVec MNAICSRGDLIADGPRASGC Nematostella vectensis XM_001638165 
monBre YNAICSRGDLESDSPSPGGC Monosiga brevicollis XM_001745398 

The known human SNPs of PLBD2 are in some cases quite radical substitutions in terms of both physical qualities of the substituted amino acid and the degree of observed phylogenetic conservation at that site. These likely result in unstable and/or inactive enzyme. Both enzymes are autosomal so compensation might occur in the recessive state, or alternately, PLBD2 and PLBD1 could fill for each other to some extent. In either case, lysosomal storage disease might not be clinically observable.

Here Q54P may actually be a mutation in the reference sequence individual (with the SNP representing wildtype) as proline is quite well conserved throughout mammals. In A204V, valine is quite a bulky substituent for a site normally restricted to small amino acids; R354C is definitely a serious mutation, no doubt attributable to a CpG hotspot; Q521K appears milder as does R524C.

The known human SNPs of PLBD1 can be analyzed similarlly. P26Q and V30L may be inconsequential as they occur in the rather unconstrained primary sequence of the N-terminus; V265I occurs at an ILV reduced alphabet; V377A and P534A are much more serious despite the aliphatic nature of alanine and likely give rise to dysfunctional protein.

Structural superposition of active sites from five NTN hydrolases
showing conserved side chains (*) and relevant main chains (....)
(adapted from Fig 6 of Lakomek et al. BMC Struct Biol.2009;9:56:)
                                            *         (*)       *    *
PLBD2 phospholipase B-like     gray   3FGR  C249 H266 W269 T330 N432 R463 mouse numbering
PLBD1 phospholipase B-like     ....   pred  C228 H245 W248 T303 N402 R433 SwissModel
Cephalosporin acylase          pink   1OQZ  S170 .... H192 .... N413 R443
Conjugated bile acid hydrolase green  2BJF  C2   .... D21  .... N175 R228
Penicillin V acylase           yellow 3PVA  C1   .... D20  .... N175 R228
Penicillin G acylase           orange 1K5S  S1   .... Q23  .... N241 R263

Human SNPs resulting in amino acid substitions:
PLBD2:                PLBD1:
 Q54P   rs7965471    P26Q   rs1141509
 A204V  rs12231990   V30L   rs12296104
 R354C  rs56935204   V265I  rs7957558
 Q521K  rs17852787   V377A  rs2287541
 R524C  rs12425042   P534A  rs1600

PLBD1 reference sequences

>PLBD1_homSap Homo sapiens (human) FLJ22662 PMID: 19019078,20093120
0 MTRGGPGGRPGLPQPPPLLLLLLLLPLLLVTAEPPKPA 1
2 GVYYATAYWMPAEKTVQVKNVMDKNGDAYGFYNNSVKTTGWGILEIRAGYGSQTLSNEIIMFVAGFLEGYLTAP 2
1 HMNDHYTNLYPQLITKPSIMDKVQDFME 2
1 KQDKWTRKNIKEYKTDSFWRHTGYVMAQIDGLYVGAKKRAILEGTK 0
0 PMTLFQIQFLNSVGDLLDLIPSLSPTKNGSLKVFKRWDMGHCSALIK 0
0 VLPGFENILFAHSSWYTYAAMLRIYKHWDFNVIDKDTSSSRLSFSSYP 1
2 GFLESLDDFYILSSGLILLQTTNSVFNKTLLKQVIPETLLSWQRVRVANMMADSGKRWADIFSKYNS 1
2 GTYNNQYMVLDLKKVKLNHSLDKGTLYIVEQIPTYVEYSEQTDVLRK 1
2 GYWPSYNVPFHEKIYNWSGYPLLVQKLGLDYSYDLAPRAKIFRRDQGKVTDTASMKYIMRYN 1
2 NYKKDPYSRGDPCNTICCREDLNSPNPSPGGCYDTK 0
0 VADIYLASQYTSYAISGPTVQGGLPVFRWDRFNKTLHQGMPEVYNFDFITMKPILKLDIK* 0

>PLBD1_braFlo Branchiostoma floridae (lancelet) XM_002595538
0 MEGRACRSCRLHHLSAVFLLFLVTIAA 1
2 GAEIQATAYLQAQGKVQVKLGVLDKQNGDAVATYDDR 2
1 LTENGWGVLNVVSGFGPKKLSDNDIMYLAGYLEGVLTQE 2
1 RIYQHYLNLYGIFFMGKSEDLVGK 0
0 VKKFYTAQDTWVRAQVKQSTDPVMKHLSYILSQYDGLVKGYNDN 0
0 LFPHVSFFQKLDIFAFQLLNGNGDTFDIIPAVNPSSRPDFSNMSRVEIDDWVSAHSHCSALVK 0
0 VLGAYENVYMSHSSWFNYAATMRIYKHYNFNIANPATATRKMSFSSYP 1
2 GYLESLDDFYLMDSGLVMLQTTNNVFNGTLYDLVKPESILAWQRVRTANMLARNGDQWGAIMNVHNS 1
2 GTYNNQYMIIDLNLIELGKTIHDGALYVVEQIPGLVMSADQTDILRA 1
2 GYWPSYNIPFYEKVYNLSGYPEFAKSQGLDYTYQLAPRAKIFRRDAGKVKDMESMKAIMRYN 1
2 DYLHDPYSKGNPCSAICCRKDLAKVGAKPDGCYDTK 0
0 VSDYYLARNLTSFAINGPTLGTGLEPFSWSDKFKISHIGLPKVYNFSFVTMTPAEL* 0

>PLBD1_strPur Strongylocentrotus purpuratus (urchin) XM_001192029
MANKFRMFKILTAFLVLVLVNLSTGELLQGTVYKQEDGTFTVSS
GIIDKQGVAYGSYNNTLFQTGWGELHLFAGYSTADNVALSDADRMYAAGILEGALTAK
QISQTLRNINISQTLQNINVTFFSAESDPEIWRRVADFFETQDAWMKGMIIERADEDP
FWEGVGLVLAQFEGLIKGYEMSQFSNASTSNGFLAMQVLNSCGDLLDLKSAVMPSLIP
DWDKLTKKEFLKFIRTSGHCSALVKICAALVKVGRFAPPFQSLLYSISSYFKSQAILK
LNSPSCQLFGIEGFLESLDDFYIMSSGLSMLQTTNNIFNKTLYKYVKPQSLLAWQRVR
VANMMARSGKDWARIVARYNSGTYNNQYMVIDRTKIKPNVAILDDALWVVEQVPTLVA
SGDQTNILRAGYWPSYNVPFYEEIYNISGYPEYAYKGGADISYQLAPRAKIFRRDQGN
VVDMESFKKIMRFNDYKNDPYSEGDPSKSICMRGDLMTSPMPNGCYDTKVTNLAMAAK
QTSFVINGPTRGDGSLPPFKWVAPFTGWSHVGLPTVYDFNFVEMCPKEL*

>PLBD1_nemVec Nematostella vectensis (anemone) XM_001638165
MTLIRNSVMITVTFVLILFVFGCHGSQKSATVYYNRGQGYSLKF
GVVDKLMGVAYGTFEDSLNTTGWYELNIVSGTGIEPYNDDVIMHAAGYLEGALTASQI
NDNYANLYGVFFKSEDDPMVAKVEKFFIEQDIWMRKMIALKSSNSSFWRQMGNIIAQF
DGLVEGYQKYPATDKALGVFAFQMLNGVGDLLDLTKALMPERMADWDHMTEKEILEKV
AMDGHCSALIKVLPAYENVFASHVSWFTYSAMLRVYKHYHLNLKDETTAAQRMSFSSY
PGFLESLDDFYIMDSKLVMLQTTNNVFNKSLYEQVVPESLFSWQRVRLANLVASSGRQ
WADIVGQYNSGTYNNQYMVLDLKLIQLNNTIQDNALWVVEQIPTLVASGDQTAILRAG
YWPSYNVPFYELVYNLSGYPDFVARHGVQFSHELAPRAKIFRRDQSMVHDLDSMKHIM
RYNDFQHDPYSQGNPMNAICSRGDLIADGPRASGCYDGKVTDFTMAQSLISHAINGPT
HEQQVPFHWSQYQFKNKHEGQPDLFNFDFVEMKPKF*

>PLBD1_monBre Monosiga brevicollis (choanoflagellate) XM_001745398
MSSLNNGIPEPLLKFLAAQFNWTRSQVAANQDDVFWQQVGLIMA
QYDGLRAGYGANVYDKHVLPEFAFQLLNGNGDFFDIIPKAVDVTKMSSREFHDWRMRN
GRCSALIKLTGDFSDLFMSHSAWYIYQAMNRIYKHCASYNFQATITHAKKISFSSYPG
YLESLDDFYLMSSGLVMLQTTNNVFNTDLQQYIQPESLQSWIRIRTATALAQTSEDWA
ELAGRHNSGTYNNQYMVMDLNKFTPGQPLLDGTLYVAEQIPGTWEYADVTKMLSLGYW
PSYNVPFFEKIYNLSGYPAVVKQHGTDDSYELAPRAKIFRRDQTTVVDLDSFKAIMRY
NDYKNDPYAKGDPYNAICSRGDLESDSPSPGGCYDTKVTTYSMALKLQSQVINGPTTS
HGLPPFSWSQFPNASHLGMPEVFNFTFETMDAGW*

PLBD2 reference sequences

>PLBD2_homSap Homo sapiens (human) PMID: 19706171,19237744,17007843
0 MVGQMYCYPGSHLARALTRALALALVLALLVGPFLSGLAGAIPAPGGRWARDGQVPPASRSRSVLLDVSAGQLLMVDGRHPDAVAWANLTNAIRETG 2
1 WAFLELGTSGQYNDSLQAYAAGVVEAAVSEE 0
0 LIYMHWMNTVVNYCGPFEYEVGYCERLKSFLEANLEWMQEEMESNPDSPYWHQ 0
0 VRLTLLQLKGLEDSYEGRVSFPAGKFTIKPLGFL 2
1 LLQLSGDLEDLELALNKTKIKPSLGSGSCSALIKLLPGQSDLLVAHNTWNNYQHMLRVIKKYWLQFREGPW 1
2 GDYPLVPGNKLVFSSYPGTIFSCDDFYILGSGL 0
0 VTLETTIGNKNPALWKYVRPRGCVLEWVRNIVANRLASDGATWADIFKRFNSGT 2
1 YNNQWMIVDYKAFIPGGPSPGSRVLTILEQIP 2
1 GMVVVADKTSELYQKTYWASYNIP 2
1 SFETVFNASGLQALVAQYGDWFSYDGSPRAQIFRRNQSLVQDMDSMVRLMR 2
1 YNDFLHDPLSLCKACNPQPNGENAISARSDLNPANGSYPFQALRQRSHGGIDVK 0
0 VTSMSLARILSLLAASGPTWDQVPPFQWSTSPFSGLLHMGQPDLWKFAPVKVSWD* 0

>PLBD2_braFlo Branchiostoma floridae (lancelet) XM_002612057
0 MAACRNIFCGRMLSCLLLFSFVFSAVSDGSKLASVRYDEAAKTYQITDKLDPSAAAWANFTDRISSTG 2
1 WSFLTVTTNEKYDDSVQAYAAGLVEGYLTRD LMYNHWLNTVGAAFCSSRSAFCKNLESFLKTNLAWMQEQIQASGDTDDYWHQ 0
0 VKLTLQQLSGLDDGYNDDPRQPSLDINPFGFL 2
1 IFQIGGDMEDLQEALKDKDSHRVLGSGSCSALVKLLPGNADLLVAHDTWDTFQSMLRIIKKYQFPFKLGGKK 1
2 GEDKIPGHTVSFSSYPGVIYSGDDFYITSASL 0
0 VAQETTIGNSNPALWKYVQPQGQVLEWLRNIVANRLANKAMDWATIFKKYNSGT 2
1 YNNQWMIVDYKTFTPNKDLPEKGLLVVLEQLP 2
1 GMVMMDDVTSVLAKQAYWPSYNSP 2
1 YFEKIFNTSGLPAMVEKYGDWFSYEHTPRANIFRRDHGKVTDISSMIKLMR 2
1 YNDFQNDPLSKCDCTPPYSAENAISARSDLNPANGTYPFSALQHRCHGGTDMK 0
0 MTSYSMHESHQMMAVSGPTHDQQQPFQWSTSDYDKQFYHLGHPDLFNFDPIHVIWFDQSDN* 0

>PLBD2_droMel Drosophila melanogaster (fruitfly) U57314 retinal lamina neuron ancestor (lama) PMID: 16077094,8892229
MERPEYDGTYCATALWTKQVGFQIENWKQQNDLVNIPTGVGRICYKDSVYENGWAQIEVETQRTYPDWVQAYAAGMLEGSLTWRNIYNQWSNTISSSCERDESTQKFCGWLRDLLTTNYHRLKRQT
EKAENDHYWHQLHLFITQLEGLETGYKRGASRARSDLEEEIPFSDFLLMNAAADIQDLKIYYENYELQNSTEHTEEPRTDQPKNFFLPSATMLTKIVQEEESPQVLQLLFGHSTAGSYSSMLRIQK
RYKFHYHFSSKLRSNTVPGVDITFTGYPGILGSTDDFYTIKGRHLHAIVGGVGIKNENLQLWKTVDPKKMVPLVARVMAANRISQNRQTWASAMSRHPFTGAKQWITVDLNKMKVQDNLYNVLEGD
DKHDDAPVVLNEKDRTAIQQRHDQLRDMVWIAEQLPGMMTKKDVTQGFLVPGNTSWLANGVPYFKNVLELSGVNYSEDQQLTVADEEELTSLASVDKYLRTHGFRGDLLGSQESIAYGNIDLKLFS
YNARLGISDFHAFAGPVFLRFQHTQPRTLEDEGQDGGVPPAASMGDERLSVSIEDADSLAEMELITERRSVRNDMRAIAMRKIGSGPFKWSEMSPVEEGGGHEGHPDEWNFDKVSPKWAW*

>PLBD2_acyPis Acyrthosiphon pisum (aphid) XM_001948827
MLSIRCILLSLLFVWALQCSATQKNQTLLAVKTDNNRITIQPKHYSVKDKEIIIGKGKFIDRINSTGWAYLEIRTSQKAKDEDQAYGAGYLEGTLTADLIYSYWFNTAKGYCTDRPNVCQQLK
DYMTTNKNWIKSKLNESDPYWYQVGLYYKQLDGLYDGYMRGKSPSTPDLTWDDLYWLNALDDLGDLSIALYPSDISNRVLGSGSCSALIKLMPDNKDILVSHATWSGYETMLRIQKRYSLRFRKS
KKSNKLIRGFDMSFSSFPGGIQSGDDFYLISSGLTTMETTIENYNDSLWSNVKPVGQVLEFVRAMVANRLADNPTDWANLFKLHNSGTYNNQWMILNYAAFQPGSPLPPRDVLHVLEQIPGHVMHD
DFTGHLINRTYWASYNVPYFPFIFNVSGNYEMEQIYGSWFSYSETPRARIFARDHVKIHCDKCMLHLMRSNNYTRD
PESRCDCSPPYSAENAISSRNDLNPANGTYPIRALGHRSHGATDVKVTSSQLFQQLQFKAIAGPTQGSNNSLGPFCWSKSDFNDKVSHLGHPDCFNFKPVLHQWSL*

>PLBD2_triAdh Trichoplax adhaerens (trichoplax) XM_002107718 introns largely conserved
0 MAQCGKFLIYFSIFIITLATLCSCQSGSVIYKDGLYTFSKGINKRAASYGTFTDKIASSG 2
1 WTYLDVHTNPQDDDFITAYAAGYVEGILTAKY IYMHWKNTVGDYCKQKSIYCQKLKSFIMKNNQWMATQIKHRPHSIYWYH 0
0 INLTLIQQKGLRDGYHKAMPHKPIDEFSFL 2
1 LIELSGDLESLETALKDEDTHHVLGSGSCSAFIKVLPDNRDLYFAHDTWTGYQTMLRIYKYYELNFSMLPKTN 1
2 VTVPGTRISFSSYPGTILSGDDYYLIGSGL 0
0 ATMETTNGNSNEKLWKYVTPSSVLEWIRTIIANRLTSSGNDWVKIFSKYNSGT 2
1 YNNQ 00 WMILDYKLFAPKRPLNPNTLWVLEQIP 2
1 GKIESADVTNVLKKQGYWASYNVP 2
1 YFSSIFNMSGNQEQAKKYGNWFTHDKCPRALIFKRDQHKVNSMESLMKLMR 2
1 YNDFKHDPLSRCNCTPPYSAENAISARSDLNPADGKYNIGALGHRCHGGTDSK STNYTMFHSGLKSYAIAGPTHEQQPPFRWSTAKFNMTKPLGHPDLFNFTRQLVSWD* 0

>PLBD2_monBre Monosiga brevicollis (choanoflagellate) introns all novel
0 MWSCGAAAAAVVAVVVLASPATATVARFVEQTDVQTTYASVFYVESDDSYVVKTENHPWDGDFEKDE 0
0 AVRIKYTPGYLVAGWDQLHVKSNSAMDDATVAYAAGYGEAQLTAEMIYNYAYNNGYDTFTPNDKLADYLAKNQAFMAASIASNRSDANGYWYHVDLILRQLQGVCDGYNSSD
FAKSFPLPCESMLAINLMGDMEDLSDALASSDEWYTEDRFFRATHCSALVKLVGGASSPSDIYISQDTWSSLNSMTRIMKRYDLNFLQ 2
1 AKGADDRIAGSSIVFSSYPGSLYSGDDFYLTSAGMAVIETTIGNSNPELYQYIVPDTVLEWIRNIMANRLASNSQTWYEVYRQFNSGT 1
2 YNNMNMILDYKQFKPQEALQDELLTIVEQIP GTVTKTDVTGYLRNMTYWGS 1
2 YNVAFDQNIRELSGANQAEQLYGPW 2
1 FSYWNTSRALIFAREQKNVSSLEDLKRLMRLNQFKTDPL 2
1 YRGWTNCTPAYTAENVIATRGDLNDP 0
0 NGIYSLSSFGLRNHVATDSKISTFSTYDSNNLNVWAIS 2
1 GPTNGPPPNQPVFNWSTSYYKDTRHRGMPEAFDFDWVNFNWPF* 0

>PLBD2_dicDis Dictyostelium discoideum (slime_mold) AAFI02000019 AF411829 introns both novel
0 MRVIRSLLLLTIAIIGSVLSQSSIDDGYTVFYSQPDNYYVKPGTFSNGVAQAIFSNEMMTTGWSFMSISSSEGLYPNDIIAAGAGYLEGYISQEMIYQNWMNMYNNEYHNVIGSD
VENWIQENLQYLQTMIDSAPSNDLYWQNVETVLTQITYMQRGYNQSVIDNGVDASQSLGITEFFLMNMDGDMIDLGPALNLTNGKQVTSPATATSPKQAFKEFMRRTGHCSALIKMTDDLSDLFSGHTTW 2
1 SSYYEMVRMFKVYNLKYLFNGQPPASKVTMFSGYPGTLSSIDDFYLLDTKIVVIETTNGLMNNNLYHLITSESVLSWIRVIVANRLATGGESWCQTFSLYNSGTYNNQ 0
0 WIIVDYNKFIKGYGALDGTLYILEQVPDYVEYGDQTAILRTGYWPSFNIPFYENIYGLTGFNETYAQFGNWFSYQASPRSMIFKRDANNIHSLTQFQAMLRYNNWQNDPFSQGNAGN
QISSRFDLVTADDPNNQYLDPDAFGGIDSKVVSADMVAALLVNAQSGPSHDNETPFTWNSQWNQKYTYAGQPTTWNFDWMTMSLQSMKPASPSSDSSSDSTTFN* 0